UPSC CSE Prelims 2012
The problem requires determining the precise living order of five professionals in a building with five flats, one above the other. Let's assign flat numbers from 1 (ground floor) to 5 (top floor).
Combining these deductions, we establish the following relationships:
Given the Doctor is in flat 3, and the sequence Engineer < MLA < IAS officer must be maintained in ascending order, these three professionals must occupy flats 2, 4, and 5 respectively. This arrangement places the Engineer below the Doctor, and the MLA and IAS officer above the Doctor, while preserving their relative order. The remaining professional is the Professor.
Placing the Professor in the remaining flat 1 satisfies the condition Professor < IAS officer (1 < 5).
Therefore, the final order from ground floor to top floor is: Professor (1), Engineer (2), Doctor (3), MLA (4), IAS officer (5).
Option 1 (Engineer, Professor, Doctor, IAS officer, MLA): In this arrangement, the MLA is in flat 5 and the IAS officer is in flat 4. This contradicts the condition that the IAS officer lives above the MLA (MLA < IAS officer).
Option 2 (Professor, Engineer, Doctor, IAS officer, MLA): In this arrangement, the MLA is in flat 5 and the IAS officer is in flat 4. This contradicts the condition that the IAS officer lives above the MLA (MLA < IAS officer).
Option 3 (IAS officer, Engineer, Doctor, Professor, MLA): In this arrangement, the Professor is in flat 4 and the IAS officer is in flat 1. This contradicts the condition that the Professor lives below the IAS officer (Professor < IAS officer).